Judge in Nevada Dismisses Immigration Lawsuit Linked to Mexican Grandmother

A federal judge in Nevada has ruled that the federal government is not legally obligated to provide reason as to why the plaintiff’s wife, a grandmother and farm worker in Mexico, has not been allowed into the United States for over two decades based on alien smuggling rules. As reported by reviewjournal.com, the judge declared that no explanation was owed say immigration lawyers that were present when the ruling was passed.

The immigration attorney that filed the lawsuit represented 69 year old Jose Isabel Esparza-Munoz who works as a landscaper in Reno and the legal counselor argued in the lawsuit that the immigration officers owed those that were denied a visa and entry a reason. That does make some sense right? Not evening a hint? Currently, the immigration officers just need to cite the section of the law under which the immigrant is disallowed into the country.

In this particular case, the woman who was denied entry and then prohibited from entering the United States for over 20 years and because she confessed to the fact that a man she had listed as her son on the application was actually her grandson that was born to her teenage daughter in 1994 when she initially applied for her visa. So she lied? That is not good!

However, Judge Robert Jones dismissed the case based upon the overriding factors that none of the particulars actually matter or come into play because of the fact that Esparza Munoz became a naturalized US citizen only after the visa was denied.

So this is like America being sued by someone who is not or was not an American and he was not at the time.

Jones added that since the spousal visa denial occurred before the person in question was even a citizen of the country, technically, there was no breach of the due process clause as only citizens would have any interest within the jurisdiction of the court in the context of spousal visa applications.

If you need legal help you should contact us. We will get back to you perhaps that same day. You can use this website to do so: Immigration.USAttorneys. You can also use this website to find that legal counselor you need as well.

Judge has been Under the Scanner for some of His Decisions

Interestingly, immigration lawyers note that Jones has come under fire for some of his decisions in cases in the recent past and the 9^th circuit have had to reverse quite a few of his rulings. In fact, the circuit even has even reprimanded Jones by taking the measure of ordering him off a particular case. But this means very little since the 9^th Circuit is known to be liberal therefore their interest in protecting Americans, defending America, keeping America safe, recognizing American borders, is questionable at best.

Unconstitutional Detainment Lawsuit Dismissed

The plaintiff in the case is Ramon Mendoza and he was pulled over for windshield obstruction in 2010 because he had his son’s boxing medal dangling from his rear view mirror. The police also uncovered that he was driving on a suspended license. They then thought he was an illegal immigrant and jailed him for the course of a weekend. They had mistaken him for another person with the same name, as reported by ketv.com.

A judge has now dismissed Mendoza’s lawsuit against the law enforcement office in question by stating that the regrettable mistakes were rectified at the earliest opportunity and that the wrongful detainment was not overly long in duration.

Don’t drive with a suspended license!

If you need help with your own immigration status or need to know how you can lawfully bring over your immediate relatives to the US on dependent visa, make sure to reach out to an immigration lawyer ASAP!